View from Row E: Ireland v Samoa


On Saturday, November 13 it was time to return to Lansdowne Road (aka the Aviva Stadium) to retake our seats in Row E of the South Stand for the Ireland v. Samoa match. Ireland’s performance in week’s game against South Africa had been a real disappointment and we all hoped for something better this time round. Regretfully, even though Ireland won 20-10, the game was a damp squib. Things weren’t made any better by the antics of some youngsters in Row C in front of us who seemed to spend the match calling their friends (by phone and in person) or shouting at Irish players who were warming up to see if they could get the players to acknowledge their existence. Of course, I know that I sound like a grumpy old man when I say this, but “it wouldn’t have happened at the old Lansdowne Road…” On the other hand, maybe the folks in Row C got value for money through the social meeting they had during the game plus the opportunity to shout inanities at players. Seems like a wasted afternoon to me, but you can’t please everyone…

Getting back to the game, the press has commented extensively on the referee’s performance at scrum engagement and I think it is fair to say that the scrums turned out to be extended, boring, and unproductive. The referee might be criticized for not being able to communicate his requirements to the players but the players, especially the Irish team in the first 60 minutes, deserve criticism for not taking action to avoid the 3 penalties and 4 free kicks that were awarded against them. However, scrums weren’t the only uninteresting phase of play in this game and nothing much appealed to the eye. In addition, players are professionals and you’d expect them to be able to work out how to avoid sanctions after the first couple of free kicks/penalties.

During the game, the first Irish try was the product of some pretty turgid pick and drive play; the second was a nice example of taking advantage of your opponent when they disengage their brain after a penalty award close to their line; Samoa scored the best try with a neat cut-in and excellent line through the Irish defense. After that, line-outs provided the highlight of the game… so you can understand that not much was going on.

As there wasn’t much to interest the rugby purist on the pitch, I took a couple of photos to illustrate the view from Row E. The photos were taken with a Nikon D700 camera equipped with a 24-120mm zoom.

The first shot is of Devon Toner winning a line-out on the Samoan 22m in the first half. This was Devon’s first cap and he did a good job of winning ball.

Devon Toner goes high to win a line-out for Ireland v Samoa

This shot shows Brian O’Driscoll forcing a 5m attacking scrum by causing Samoa to touch down behind their own line. There is quite a variety of seats and viewing positions in the Aviva Stadium. Some are “in the Gods” and far removed from the action. Others like the one we had in Row E are close to action when it happens at the South End but totally remote and detached when play goes to the North end. The best seats in the house are naturally in the middle of the pitch in the lower East and West stands.

Brian O'Driscoll forces Samoa to concede a 5m scrum

The last shot shows the Irish team lined up to receive the Samoan challenge before the game. Not quite the New Zealand haka, but worthwhile seeing all the time.

The Irish team face the challenge from Samoa

Saturday’s game was a disappointment, but tonight everything is reset as I’m in Limerick for the Munster vs. Australia game. It’s good to see that touring teams are still willing to play non-international games outside the major centres and I am looking forward to seeing how an admittedly weakened Munster squad (many of their top-line players are in the Irish team preparing for the game against New Zealand on Saturday next) play against the “green and gold”.

– Tony

Advertisements

About Tony Redmond ("Thoughts of an Idle Mind")

Exchange MVP, author, and rugby referee
This entry was posted in Rugby and tagged , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

One Response to View from Row E: Ireland v Samoa

  1. Dan Wallace says:

    The view from row s behind you was much the same.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s