Communications failure in Twickenham

On March 13 I was back at Twickenham to be the TV Match Official (TMO) for the England v Scotland Six Nations game. This is the oldest international fixture and was first played in 1871, so there’s a bit of history and whenever the two teams come together you can be sure of a dogfight.

The game ended 22-16 for England but the scoreline disguises some minor panic for the communications technicians.  It all started in the 59th minute when referee Romain Poite pulled up with a calf strain. He was replaced by assistant referee Jerome Garces, also of France and Andrew Small took over as the second assistant referee. This was the first time that a referee was replaced in the middle of a Six Nations international and while the protocol for such a replacement is well understood and the switch performed flawlessly, the communications equipment started to malfunction immediately afterwards. As normal, I was located in the TV Director’s outside broadcast unit and there was no communications between this unit and the referee. Other problems existed on the field as the assistant referees couldn’t hear the referee either.

Fortunately England decided to change four players the next time that the ball went out of play and the technicians were able to change the on-field radios and batteries. However, while this restored communications from the referee and between the referee and his assistants, he couldn’t hear me. Losing communications isn’t a real issue unless a decision has to be referred to the TMO.

Scotland duly went over the line in the 74th minute. There was some doubt whether the ball was grounded correctly as it squirted away from the scorer, Max Evans, immediately afterwards. Jerome stopped play and referred the decision to the TMO. I could hear the question (“try or no try”), but couldn’t respond. All hell broke loose in the outside broadcast unit as the BBC attempted to restore the link but in the meantime a decision to award the try was made – the only problem was how to tell the referee. The BBC director told the floor manager (the person responsible for running coverage from the sideline) to tell the referee but Jerome didn’t know who this person was and quite correctly declined to accept a decision from him.

Before the game, Andrew Pearce, the number 5 official (all international and high-profile rugby matches have two replacement officials on the sideline; most of the time they control substitutions and temporary suspensions or as in this case, the number 4 goes on in the case of an injury) and I had exchanged mobile phone numbers and I called him to relay the decision. Jerome was happy to accept the information from Andrew and the try was awarded. While it was good to make the right decision, it was disappointing that we had to depend on a mobile phone – and I was lucky that we both used O2 as I’ve been told since that other phone providers don’t have a reliable signal around Twickenham.

Despite valiant efforts from Scotland, England closed the game out afterwards and now look forward to coming to Dublin on March 19 when they’ll attempt to win the Grand Slam. We’ll just have to see about that!

– Tony


About Tony Redmond

Lead author for the Office 365 for IT Pros eBook and writer about all aspects of the Office 365 ecosystem.
This entry was posted in Rugby and tagged , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to Communications failure in Twickenham

  1. Phil Day says:

    Hi Tony,

    Thanks for the explantaion. One of the intersting side effects from watching all of this on the TV was that for a while it was a bit of a flashback to how things used to sound before we had the feed from the Ref”s mike all the way though the game. I hadn’t realised how much of the Ref and Players chatter came through normally these days. Quite amusing to hear the commentators struggle once or twice to guess what the decision was for – obvioulsy they were missing the feed too 🙂

    On a related point, and a TMO do you think the Wales try could have been referred ?

    Take Care,

    • The current IRB protocol doesn’t strictly allow for the situation that occurred for the Welsh try. There’s a case to be made that the referee could have asked the TMO “is there any reason why I cannot award this try”, but it would be unusual for a referee to do that after receiving a strong confirmation from his assistant that everything was OK. I think that this is an area that the IRB will have to look at and hopefully they’ll do it before the World Cup.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.